Review: Up
Now, the longer version...
[PAUSE FOR SPOILERS
It has a talking dog and a zeppelin. Sold!
The story, in a nutshell: An old man, recently widowed and having trouble navigating modern life, decides to abandon modern life and have the adventure he and his wife always wanted, with a little help from hundreds of balloons. He is accompanied by a lawyer-friendly Boy Scout, a talking dog, and a giant bird; and learns, in the end, that the greatest adventures of all take place inside.
In all sincerity, as much of a Pixar fanboy as I am generally, Up is truly an amazing film. Pixar pulls out all the stops for this one, down to the tiniest detail, and produces something truly magical.
The visuals are, of course, astounding; Pixar has outdone themselves yet again in the visual department, creating a vision of South America and of the inside of an old man's home that genuinely left me in awe. Their characters are beautifully animated, and perhaps more importantly, subtly animated; so much of the story is told through facial expressions, gestures, and interaction with the environment (I squeed a little every time Carl put his hand on the mailbox) that I might forget the film was animated if the animation wasn't so beautiful. The sequence showing Carl and Ellie's courtship and marriage is truly breathtaking in its capacity to show, without a single line of audible dialog, the entirety of a couple's lives together.
Second only to the animation, though, are the characters. Just because their animators are so talented does not mean Pixar has shirked on their writing staff; the characters and events in this film are vivid and fully realized. Watching the character of Carl progress from the start of the film to the end, I was put in mind of actually seeing a time-lapse biography of some very real person who happened to look like two boxes stacked on top of each other. And the portrayal of his romance with Ellie was simply adorable.
The story...well, the story is where this movie might fall flat if it were a different movie. The plot itself is nicely organic and ties together well, but there are a few plot holes (the science teacher I saw this with had some choice comments about the buoyancy and staying power of helium balloons) and one or two places where characters were left holding the Idiot Ball (why would you fly your house to South America and not lock all your doors?). However, nitpicking like this is nitpicking for the sake of nitpicking; because if you're worried about this stuff, you are missing the point.
Up is not a movie about the real world. Up is a movie about wonder and adventure. Things happen not because they are realistic, but because they are beautiful or dramatic or sweet; the story running on mythological logic. From the moment Carl and Ellie's home floats away using a chimney full of balloons and two bedsheets, we have left the Campbellian world of the every day and moved to something far more likely to make us grin; and the wonder of the South American adventure ends with the sweet and utterly tear-jerking touch of a shot of their house, exactly where Ellie always dreamed it would be. They are the front and back covers of a fairytale, conveniently placed so you know when to enjoy the ride through a child's eyes.
And really, that's what this movie is about. This movie is about wonder, and all the little places you can find it, and our tendency to let life pass by without wonder, or to let the wonder in your lives pass us by without remark. It's about obsessing over little details of the past and refusing to see the amazing things happening in front of you (Charles Muntz being the totemic representation thereof—watch the events during the climactic battle), and the smile that comes to your face when you realize, as Mr. Incredible said a few Pixar films back, that sometimes the people you love are your greatest adventure.
Before I give up on spoilers, I have to end by saying, I am continually astounded by how dark Pixar is willing to wax in its films. Up has an implied miscarriage and/or fertility problem, complete with utterly depressed couple, a sad stunned man sitting at a funeral, and as far as I can tell the first on-screen depiction of blood in a Pixar film (caused by the main character, no less). It's not bad, by any means—I am an advocate of people, kids included, being forced into seeing the ups and downs of life, and it certainly gives extra lift to the joy of leaving the everyday—but it is surprising to me that they get away with it. Frankly, it gives me a little hope for the future of kid's entertainment, which is sorely lacking after some of this movie's previews...
[PAUSE TO END SPOILERS]
In the end, this is more of the Pixar magic, come to startling 3-D life. It is a beautiful movie for both child and adult, and you should probably consider bringing some Kleenex. It is odd to think that this is de rigeur for Pixar...but it is, and I hope it never stops, because it's good to know that someone in this world places such a high value on wonder.
Labels: reviews
