Very short version: Wow. I mean,
wow. Wait, what?
Short version: A visually stunning, beautifully crafted, highly imaginative movie with a plot that would put even a five-year-old to sleep. Deeply enjoyable but almost doesn't need sound.
Long version,
MIT SPOILER:
The summary: Nine unnerving and adorable rag dolls awaken to a world reduced to trash and rubble, and over the course of an hour and a half's storytelling uncover the truth about the world they have fallen into and their existence. One among them digs deeper than the others, unleashing something ancient and horrible and then righting his own wrong as best it can be righted, all leading to a conclusion that no-one understands but somehow involves Paracelsus.
I will start with the good:
9 is beautiful. Not traditional, statuesque, my-pants-are-tight beautiful, nor the kind that makes you warm inside; Shane Acker's vision is dark and alluring in a very unique way, a little steampunk, a little cyberpunk, a little good-old-fashioned punk. The movie turns everyday objects into fantastic creatures and contraptions—the only thing I couldn't identify, my girlfriend identified for me—and invests it all with a life and a horror that never seems to step outside the bounds of the objects thus incorporated.
The cinematography, likewise, must be praised. The backgrounds in this film are phenomenal, the action sequences exquisitely choreographed to make full use of the settings the characters are placed in, and the level of detail in everything is astounding without looking cluttered—or rather, without looking the bad kind of cluttered;
9's world is definitely way past its quota for junk.
In addition to the visuals, I have to praise this movie's vision. The dark future it depicts is archetypal enough for everyone to recognize it, but occupies a weird anachronistic space all its own; the process for creating the rag dolls and the history of the world up to the beginning of the narrative are clearly well-thought out; and the real-world ideas seem well-researched and brilliantly applied, and all of this background is only shoved down our throats when needed—there is plenty that is left tacit and implied for the viewer to unpack. All throughout the movie are little touches that show just how much thought and care went into this film. Acker clearly has a monumental imagination, and I look forward to seeing more from him.
However, this level of detail and thought is exactly why the one weak point is so overwhelming, and that weak point: the movie's story. Not the background, mind you—the background has a great deal of hidden depth—the actual plot of what occurs in the course of the movie. The plot is so basic that it can be predicted more or less from the get-go; it's like someone took Campbell's Hero's Journey and glued the contents of a junk drawer to it. We recognize the narrative elements as soon as they are introduced, watch for their usual applications, and are never once surprised at how things turn out.
There are twists, I suppose, in the form of unraveling the mysteries of what occurred prior to the rag dolls being created, and their creator's intentions for them, but those are never fully explored. What's more, the ending is unsatisfying in the extreme. While the triumph over the Big Bad and the release of those put into, as far as we can tell, perpetual torment are certainly a good denouement, the dark science and cool alchemical ideas of the rest of the movie suddenly become strange fairytale hand-waves. The movie clearly intends us to ask ourselves what happens next for the surviving rag dolls, but it doesn't care to explain why the talisman is unleashing some but not all of their souls into the air, nor why that makes it rain, nor why the raindrops are teeming with little green soul-bits. (As one of my co-viewers put it, "What I learned today is that bacteria are the souls of old people." If you're reading this despite spoiler warnings, you have to watch to understand; I can't make it make sense.)
END SPOILERS.But the weak plot aside,
9 is in no way a bad movie. The visuals and imagination that went into it are stunning, and while the story's progression is weak the ideas behind it are so originally executed, if not wholly original, that I can't see fit to have much complaint with the movie overall. I give it four out of five scissor-beaked creatures from my nightmares. I enjoyed it greatly, and gasped in wonder in some places, and I fully plan on owning this baby on DVD.
Yes, I will be the terrible parent who shows this to their children. Did you expect anything less from me?
Labels: reviews